Monthly Giving Manager
Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe | La Crosse, Wisconsin
Reports to: Director of Annual Giving
Employment status: Full-time; exempt
About the Shrine
The Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in La Crosse, Wisconsin, is a Catholic pilgrimage destination dedicated to serving the spiritual needs of those who suffer poverty in body and soul. Through prayer, the sacraments, and opportunities to grow in the Catholic faith, the Shrine welcomes pilgrims seeking spiritual renewal, thanksgiving, and solace. Our employees support this mission through their work and their care for pilgrims, benefactors, and one another.
Position Overview
The Monthly Giving Manager builds and strengthens relationships with Our Lady’s Messengers (OLM), the Shrine’s community of monthly donors. Reporting to the Director of Annual Giving, this position helps donors understand the impact of their generosity, deepens their connection to the Shrine’s mission, and encourages continued and increased support.
As a collaborative member of the annual giving team, the manager provides personalized donor outreach, coordinates member communications and experiences, and supervises the Monthly Giving Callers.
Key Responsibilities
- Serve as the primary stewardship contact for Our Lady’s Messengers, conducting regular, personalized phone outreach to express gratitude, answer questions, and build lasting relationships.
- Invite members to consider increasing their monthly gifts through thoughtful conversations that respect each donor’s interests and circumstances.
- Accurately document donor interactions, preferences, commitments, and gift updates in the donor database, maintaining complete records and protecting confidential information.
- Coordinate and carry out communications specifically for OLM members, including exclusive email updates.
- Collaborate with the Annual Giving Communications Manager to ensure donor communications, event invitations, and outreach are consistent with the Shrine’s mission, messaging, and annual giving strategy.
- Plan and coordinate special events and experiences for OLM members that deepen engagement and encourage continued support.
- Train, supervise, and coach Monthly Giving Callers, establishing clear expectations for donor care, outreach, messaging, and accurate recordkeeping.
- Lead by example through active participation in donor calls and ongoing feedback and support for callers.
- Monitor outreach results, donor feedback, retention, and giving increases; prepare useful reports and recommend improvements to the monthly giving program.
Qualifications
- A practicing Catholic with a sound understanding of the Catholic faith and a commitment to the Shrine’s mission is preferred.
- Familiarity with the liturgical year, Catholic devotions, and feast days.
- Knowledge of the apparitions of Our Lady of Guadalupe; familiarity with the Shrine’s history and activities is preferred.
- Excellent interpersonal, verbal, and written communication skills, including attentive listening and confidence speaking with donors by phone.
- Experience in fundraising, donor relations, customer service, or a related relationship-focused role.
- Strong organizational skills, attention to detail, and the ability to manage ongoing outreach alongside communications and events.
- Ability to handle personal and financial information with discretion and confidentiality.
- Proficiency with common office software and the ability to learn and use a donor database or customer relationship management (CRM) system.
- Ability to train, encourage, and provide constructive feedback to others; previous supervisory or coaching experience is preferred.
- Ability to work independently and collaboratively across departments.
How to Apply
Please submit a letter of interest and resume to Laura Antonie at Lantonie@guadalupeshrine.org with “Monthly Giving Manager” in the subject line.
